Six years. A lot has been mentioned within the final six years about Staff Cherry’s close to radio silence on Hole Knight: Silksong. Guarantees from Microsoft concerning the sport popping out “within the subsequent 12 months” in 2022. No playable demo since E3 2019. No Kickstarter updates. And a furore of hungry followers whipping themselves right into a frenzy and constructing a whole group on memes and anguish.
Then, on nineteenth August, we came upon that was about to vary: “The countdown is on! Be a part of us in 48 hours for a particular announcement about Hole Knight: Silksong!” Bloomberg reporter Jason Schreier revealed he’d spoken to the devs final month and promised to share “the story behind why Silksong took seven years to make…”. Even Geoff Keighley bought in on the motion and, throughout Gamescom 2025 Opening Night time Dwell, shared a quick snippet of (blurry) gameplay. The hype was reaching fever pitch.
And, as promised, at 3:30pm BST on Thursday twenty first August, the information dropped. Silksong is lastly popping out on 4th September 2025. Staff Cherry’s co-founders Ari Gibson and William Pellen’s story was on the market. Was there drama? Fireworks?
Nope. It was all superbly anticlimactic in the absolute best manner; a sub-two minute trailer that confirmed us this was “extra Hole Knight“. No over-explaining mechanics or particulars. Some glimpses of boss fights, cities, characters, and motion. And, in fact, that launch date.
In truth, you may go even additional — the Silksong launch trailer is structured virtually identically to the Hole Knight equal, proper all the way down to the language. “Face over 140 ferocious foes” and “Descend into an unlimited, ruined world” in Hole Knight is now “Battle over 200 ferocious foes” and “Ascend to the height of a haunted kingdom” in Silksong. It is not delicate, however I am going to say it once more: Silksong is extra Hole Knight.
Watching that Silksong trailer was like seeing an previous buddy after an extended time frame; an occasion that you simply construct up in your head, just for it to be a very regular second. Final month, I visited the UK for the primary time in two years, and I organized to satisfy up with a buddy; I fearful, I overthought issues, I considered what to put on. Then once we did meet, we hugged, requested one another how we had been, and chatted like we would by no means been aside. Utterly atypical, similar to this trailer drop.
I could not consider a greater manner for Silksong to reintroduce itself to the world, on Staff Cherry’s personal phrases. For years, after each Nintendo Direct, each Indie World, each Summer season Recreation Fest, individuals decried that it was over, clown paint and hair on the prepared, frustration boiling over. There needed to be one thing happening, proper?
But, there wasn’t — at the very least, that is what Gibson and Pellen instructed Schreier. Staff Cherry is not right here to supply the viewers with juicy gossip or to gas the fandom with much more fireplace. “Why did it take so lengthy?” Schreier says within the piece. The response? They had been having enjoyable, blissfully ignorant (largely) of the whirlwind of ‘Silkposting’ on-line: “This entire factor is only a car for our creativity anyway. It’s good to make enjoyable issues.”
Whether or not that is true or not is one other story, nevertheless it’s refreshing to listen to that the group (Gibson, Pellen, Jack Vine, and composer Christopher Larkin) took the time to do no matter they wished, and so they had the cash to do it. Look, I’m the primary particular person to confess that I am excited to play Silksong, and I acknowledge that video video games media and protection (together with us!) has, partially, contributed to the effervescent pot of Silksong fever. However I’ve additionally by no means actually bought the voracious must have this sport in individuals’s palms.
Staff Cherry was by no means going to launch Silksong if it wasn’t prepared — the devs mentioned this again in 2019. We learn so many tales about crunch, strain from higher-ups, and video games failing to hit unrealistic deadlines and targets. Creators must be allowed to flourish and make regardless of the heck they need, regardless of how lengthy it takes, and we should not grief them for it.
Might the group have mentioned one thing? Perhaps, however as Gibson argues, “We felt like continued updates had been simply going to bitter individuals on the entire thing as a result of all we might actually say is, ‘We’re nonetheless engaged on it.’” Hole Knight was a distinct beast, a studio’s very first sport, and so there was virtually an obligation to maintain individuals within the loop. Silksong grew to become a lot greater than it was ever meant to be.
Lots has modified within the six years since Silksong’s final playable demo, however Silksong and Staff Cherry stay defiant; their timeline is their very own. That playable demo at Gamescom 2025? Apparently it was virtually an identical to the E3 2019 (RIP) one. Silksong is probably going an iteration of Hole Knight — and we have seen a number of the finest sequels ever made with iterative installments like Tremendous Mario Galaxy 2 and Tears of the Kingdom, and even smaller video games like Freedom Planet 2, one other indie that went by means of a long-development cycle.
The Metroidvania (or action-platformer, or search-action, no matter you need to name it) was already blooming previous to Hole Knight’s launch, however now it is really exploded. Blasphemous, 9 Sols, Prince of Persia: The Misplaced Crown, Timespinner, Crypt Custodian, Ender Lilies & Magnolia — these are only a few of my favourites I’ve performed that launched between Hole Knight and Silksong. And whereas Hole Knight may sit on the prime of that pantheon for me, even surpassing Symphony of the Night time and Tremendous Metroid, Silksong must be handled as simply one other sport launch. Detach it from the hype machine and simply get pleasure from it for what it’s.
As a substitute of specializing in whether or not Silksong will reside as much as the hype (I do not even know if that is doable), or already proclaiming that it is “GOTY 2025” (it is not even out but — and hey, perhaps I am going to find yourself saying that in December), we should always rejoice that Staff Cherry made a sport on their very own phrases, in their very own time. That must be the norm on this trade, and it is a darn disgrace it is not.
What did you consider Silksong’s Launch Trailer? Tell us your ideas within the feedback.
